FuelPHP Forums

Hi, see: https://github.com/fuel/docs/issues/287 I can't judge it is bug or no. So I just ask here. I want to know 'Is this bug? or not?'. On this timeout error showed, I never saw it was PHP timeout, because I set timeout in config file. (On the time, I forget to set 5 sec, I belived 30 sec. set. )

'smtp' => array(
   'host'  => 'smtp.gmail.com',
   'port'  => 465,
   'username' => 'my-account@gmail.com',
   'password' => 'my-password',
   'timeout' => 5,
  ),

  /**
   * Newline
   */
  'newline' => "\r\n",

I knew Google smtp nener return anything, then the socket frozen and over 30 seconds, it went to timeout on PKGPATH/email/classes/email/driver/smtp.php @ line 215, 'while($str = fgets($this->smtp_connection, 512))'. In smtp.php, seems timeout is set on just one part :

/**
  * Connects to the given smtp and says hello to the other server.
  */
 protected function smtp_connect()
 {
  $this->smtp_connection = @fsockopen(
   $this->config['smtp']['host'],
   $this->config['smtp']['port'],
   $error_number,
   $error_string,
   $this->config['smtp']['timeout']
  );

I google-d fsocketopen, this timeout for only connection. It never work for each read/write statement for socket. So I google-d more. And found a sample code with Japanese comments. So translate in English, it say:

// connect by socket with HOST:PORT. (try TIMEOUT seconds)
if ($fp = @fsockopen(HOST, PORT, err_no, err_str, TIMEOUT)) {

// after connected, set timeout 5 seconds.
socket_set_timeout($fp, 5);

// get meta data of the socket
$socket_data_arr = stream_get_meta_data($fp);

// sending socket
fputs($fp, $hoge);

// when there are response, get them

$buf = ""

// if $socket_data_arr[time_out"] is true, sending is timeout

while (!feof($fp) && !$socket_data_arr["time_out"]) {
$buf .= fgets($fp, 1024);

}

fclose($fp);

}

I don't know this is correct handling, but I get idea to check timeout for socket. It is done by stream_set_timeout(), socket_set_timeout() is alias of this fanction. And check stmp.php, but no there both functions. So frozen at fgets() line, and reached php timeout. So, Is it bug? or not?